17 October 2016

MIDI DIN Vs MIDI USB Latency

A small article where I share you my user experience about the MIDI latency between the 5 pins DIN connectors and the USB plugs.

I want to compare the speed between a MIDI signal through the MIDI DIN vs MIDI USB. I want to be sure that USB is too fast that my “old-fashioned” MIDI DIN and not add latency when I play.

For the test:
A Nord Stage (master) controls a MOTIF (slave) :

nordstage2

MASTER –>

MotifXF

–> Slave

 


1: With the classic MIDI DIN (5 pins), we obtain the following result : 2 ms latency between the first signal generated by NORD STAGE and the second generated by the MOTIF.

midi-din

NORD STAGE — MIDI DIN –> MOTIF XF = 2 ms


2nd: With USB cable into a router. And using the small MIDI Patchbay software to route the USB MIDI signal between devices. The computer used, is a MacBook 2012. Same result : 2 ms latency between the two synthesizers. So there is no additional latency when using USB MIDI even through a small freeware.

midi-usb

NORD STAGE — MIDI USB –> MOTIF XF = 2 ms


3rd: With 2 different MIDI interfaces (EMU 1X1 and Iconnectivity MIDI4+), produces the following result : 5 ms latency. Probably due to the USB/MIDI Conversion.

emu-midi

NORD STAGE — Iconnectivity MIDI4+ Interface –> MOTIF XF = 5 ms


4th: But this latency is reduced to 3 ms when using the internal routing of the interface (Iconnectivity) between its various MIDI DIN plugs. Therefore, the interface latency is 1 ms.

din-to-din-via-interface

NORD STAGE — IConnectivity midi4 + (DIN) –> MOTIF XF = 3 ms


In summary :

  • MIDI DIN and MIDI USB have exactly the same latency.
  • But a conversion from one format to another will add a few ms (3 ms in my test)
  • The best thing you can do is to plug in all MIDI DIN or all USB MIDI.

by Stefpiano from Keyboardwaves

PS : The USB MIDI connection, after hours of test on OSX, is extremely stable, even through an extension and a passive USB router.

Comments

One thought on “MIDI DIN Vs MIDI USB Latency
  1. Matt Milford

    Fun fact: sound travels 0.6m in 2ms. I can’t tell that the latency is higher if anyone moves my keyboard speaker, so most people can’t hear it!

     
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

wp-puzzle.com logo